ideasarehere

July 21, 2010

Solution vs. Engagement

Filed under: creativity,internet,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 14:25

It’s funny that I’m now kind of hooked to this whole topic of engagement, and this might be just a temporal selective perception issue, but as long as it lasts, it seems sensible to make use of it to get a different perspective on our lives.

Today, a friend called out for help on formatting his Master Thesis, and I thought this would be an easy-to-fix issue, so I posted a link to a tutorial on the web. As it turns out, it didn’t fix his problem. So I asked him to send his document, and because it took a little longer, I tried to replicate the issue on my computer, and got back to him after 10 minutes with a solution which worked, and we were both happy. (His file came in 20 mins later. Praise email.)

The important point is, not only was he happy that his problem was solved, but also that someone had spend their time to make this happen. If he had searched a little more, I’m sure he’d have found a solution on the web himself, or he’d have gotten some more links from people who’d have cared a little. But in the end, the value is the personal interaction. We often tend to forget that solutions (as well as problems) don’t exist by themselves — they’re being created by real people. And the value lies in the creation process, not in its outcome.

That’s why a solution is never as valuable as the engagement that led to it.

July 20, 2010

Outcome of an Experiment

Filed under: internet — Erik Dobberkau @ 13:50

Five days ago, as promised, I asked my Facebook peers (about 160 people) to post an important question. If all that people need is a concrete opportunity this would suffice to activate their latent need for expression, I thought. Any bets?

Guess what, nothing happened. Well, not quite. I had prepared myself for some mockery and the like, but even that didn’t happen. Silence.

And once again, the question becomes: Why don’t people engage? Now we’ve successfully eliminated the lack of opportunity as sole explanation, what else is there?

  • Personal reasons: Why should they respond to someone who’s not a leader in that field or at all in their opinion? Reversing that argument uncovers that people might respond to a leader’s question only because she’s a leader, not because people genuinely want to.
  • Reward: There was nothing in it for them. Or not enough that was plain to see.
  • Timing: The question came in on Thursday, but they had all their important questions sorted out by Wednesday. You bet.
  • Fear. Responding to someone asking you to post an important question is considered as serious exposure rather than taking the opportunity to get something going.

The problem is, you cant’t really find out. When people are not willing to ask the question itself, it’s hard to believe they are more willing to tell you the reason for their behavior (most of them wouldn’t know anyway). All you can to is consider this circumstance. Trying to overcome the three real obstacles at once is hardly possible without ridiculing yourself. Ask any advertiser about this and brace yourself for an hour-long lament.

Yet there was one response (the only one) that made me think enough to write a single post about it in the next few days.

July 15, 2010

Engagement (and what is not)

Filed under: internet,media — Erik Dobberkau @ 09:11

The liner notes to Hugh’s drawing have it. Now it’s engagement. Just having finished Clay Shirky’s “Cognitive Surplus” , I wondered why it is that, despite the fact it being easier than ever before, people do not engage in meaningful conversation, supporting a cause or starting their own movement. And the answer is quite simple (again): fear.

In a world where people are connected 24/7, it is technically easy to find something you care about. What hinders the engagement is the inconvenience of the process, and more important, the risk you’re putting yourself at. Risk in terms of reputation. As Chris Anderson points out in “Free!”, reputation is something that people are very keen on especially in online social networks. In this context, for some people virtualization has not brought more freedom but more restraints, because they submit themselves to peer pressure not only in the workplace or in private, but since they usually have the same peers online they are now feeling (and sometimes being) watched continuously.

The other important issue is (in)convenience. Most people who have grown up without the Internet are still in a consumer mindset today. They still have the notion of the web being an extension of traditional media, a circumstance which traditional media is still enforcing on their web sites. With their online content being just a repetition of the broadcast or the print, they keep pushing back their visitors to the traditional channels, be it the TV screen or the newspaper stand. They don’t want people to engage online, because everone who does is one consumer lost. But they don’t have to worry, because people act the way they’ve been trained to, they consume web pages. Clicking a “Like” button is not engagement. Re-posting privacy warnings on Facebook isn’t either.

Engagement generates long-term value, and long-term value is the enemy of consumption, because it relies on immediate decay of value after purchase, which doesn’t necessarily have to include a monetary transaction (it does, but that’s a hidden one between the provider and a third party, say an advertiser). And once people figure out something has no long-term value, they stop supporting it. You can see this when we revisit the Pretzel vs. Tokio Hotel fad: 5 months later, the Pretzel group now has about 644,000 members (and remember, they got 500,000 within their first 15 days of existence), whereas the Tokio Hotel fan group now has more than 650,000 . Once again, the reason behind this is quite obvious: Being the fan of an artist has a long-term value, what happens here is the prerequisite to engagement: a tribe is growing, so now whoever is inside this tribe has an organized platform to start engagement. On the other hand, being the fan of a pretzel is fun for the moment, and the inevitable media hype rewards ervery member with the satisfaction of having been part of it, but no more. This is not a tribe, because no one seriously cares about the reason the have gathered for — this is consumption.

I’ll do an experiment today: I’ll ask people to post an important question, on Facebook. I’m curious to see what happens if you ask people to do something instead of waiting for something to happen. Results coming soon.

July 8, 2010

The Hardest Part still remains

Filed under: business,creativity,marketing,video — Erik Dobberkau @ 18:39

A few days ago a somewhat heated debate went on at Motionworks. Well, it wasn’t as much of a discussion because in general the participants agreed on the topic. One thing that was still surprising was the lack of culture and, say, humilty and appreciation in the discussion itself. How hard can it be to write “Thank you”? But that’s not my point today.

What’s worth a closer look is the topic of the aforementioned issue, namely: “Does the increasing amount of online tutorials devalue the (established) artists?”

No. Thank you for reading.

Okay, let’s roll this out a bit. Yes, there are hundreds of tutorials online, even for free, only the number and variety of which could easily let one assume that you can learn how to be a Motion Graphics Designer in 2 months. And this assumption is of course ridiculous, because teaching some a technique doesn’t make them an artist. No one’s becoming the next van Gogh, Picasso or Warhol because you show them how to hold a brush.

One field where teaching people how to do stuff has actually boosted the business is cooking. Thanks to all the Nigellas and Jamies there are more people going more often to restaurants spending more money. That’s counterintuitive because we assume that if we tell people how to perform or improve daily actions, they do it all themselves. But what has happened is that people got more educated on the art of cooking and were willing to spend more money on good cuisine.

And there’s another ingredient that’s essential for creating: inspiration. Without the 1% of inspiration the 99% perspiration are not work, they’re labour. People don’t pay a lot for stuff that hasn’t got “it”. So why go there at all?

The hardest part, figuring what to put on the empty canvas, has not been changed. Knowledge of a series of techniques won’t let you do that. That’s just copying. Like assembling LEGOs, it’s fine and good to follow the instructions and build the spaceship, but it’s great when you mix the pieces of several boxes to model a submarine. But the real art is inventing LEGO. Something that enables people to craft with their creativity. Like the Web 2.0, in a certain way.

So the hardest part is still the same, and people who can solve it will still get paid well. It’s only that the perceived entrance barrier to this field has been lowered. But this doesn’t change the game. Not yet.

June 23, 2010

Differentiate

Filed under: business,creativity,internet,marketing — Erik Dobberkau @ 16:08

The other day I was visiting a couple of web sites of media production companies, and what you notice pretty soon is that they all look the same. Not literally of course, some designs are fancier than others, but the overall structure of the sites are very much the same. Which raises the question of why that is. And the answer is: That’s how it has to be. Not for me, but the one who had to decide how the page should be set up thought exactly this. And of course he got there by looking at the competition’s web page. And as always, the first one to achieve [whatever] sets the bar for the next in line. That’s how a common understanding or notion of anything is created: silent agreement and the fear of probably being ridiculed for standing out.

The obvious thing to do is to be completely different. People visiting your corporate web site do it for only one out of two reasons: they either want to buy or they want to be hired. They don’t really want to look at fancy photos of your staff. They don’t want to read pretentious online resumés. Both of these are exclusion criteria. It’s much easier to say “I don’t like how they look” or “they’re too old” or “they’re too young”. None of this information is intruiging in some way to make me buy your stuff. Neither is a job description for a creative professional that reads like a classified ad for a garbage picker’s job (but of course expecting the candidates to submit outstanding samples of work).

So what to do? It’s dead simple. Give your visitors a vivid experience. Have a video for customers and people looking for jobs. If you want to be on screen, be on screen! Talk to them. Say how happy you are that they’re here and give them the tour. Be real. Be tangible. Have one video for customers and one for job seekers. Both care about different aspects of your business and need different information. And for the job seekers, give them an actual task. Ad agencies have been doing this for long, almost every major agency has some sort of copy test available online that challenges applicants to come up with great ideas. Why not do this for designers or editors or even bakers as well? This helps you a lot more analyzing their future potential instead of their past. Maybe they just worked on silly projects that never challenged them to unfold their potential — do you want to do the same by turning them down up front? That’s what you do if you just read resumés.

So if you want to be as different as you claim in your copy, show it to everyone. Showing that you care is more than enough for starters.

June 16, 2010

Change (the other kind)

Filed under: business,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 07:53

The other day it occured to me that change happens in generally two ways.

One is the kind everybody thinks of first. It’s dramatic and unique, paradigm-shifting, curve-jumping. Change that is considered revolutionary. Changing the game within the blink of an eye. It’s what VCs are looking for, it’s sellable because everybody knows straight away “Wow, this changes everything!” Well, sometimes they don’t and it takes them a little longer. But then everybody starts looking for the next big thing.

As it turns out, there is another kind of change, one that is constant and slow. This is the kind of change that renders you obsolete in different ways:

  • your job requirements have shifted over the last 15 years
  • your customers have aged and are no longer your target group
  • your service has been replaced by a free or cheaper resource

It’s tricky because this change doesn’t come with a lot of fanfare or other dramatic indicators. It just happens. It’s evolutionary.

The funny thing is, you can hardly sell the second kind to anyone to make money, right? People don’t see a need to move as long as there’s only a little difference to what they already have. They want the new model with hundreds of new features — or no change at all (even if it’s a fad). The stupidity here is the concept of thinking. People buy in a way they’ve always bought. Maybe because that’s how they were accustomed to buying as kids and didn’t think it over. At least it’s a good explanation why some senior management acts like, well, kids.

[And even though I don’t want to get political here, I just wonder when Mr Obama advertised the coming of change, did anyone ever ask what kind of change he meant? I don’t think so. People just assumed he meant dramatic and revolutionary — and no one really thought about how to pull all of this off. And, picking up the last post, when the financial crisis came as a revolutionary change, everybody was impressed (and shocked, yes) because it was hardly on anyone’s radar. From where we are now, there is little chance that some revolution will turn things the other way. No matter how many people are waiting in despair.]

June 12, 2010

NOW is the new standard

Filed under: business,marketing,media,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 12:27

Last time I checked, it was 2010. Doing some basic math, I calculated the financial crisis (the one that came first to the market, not the me-too crisis) happened two years ago. Some economies have recovered, some have not.

Still people are having real trouble to let go off the idea that we are still in the middle of a crisis. Sorry, we are not. Maybe they are. Because it’s easier to believe that the new standard is just a temporary phenomenon. And it’s easier to sell to a media audience — but not to shareholders. Where’s the initiative? Waiting for a saviour to come isn’t.

I might be going out on a limb here, but this could mean compared to other religions,  Christians will have a longer lasting disadvantage regarding this issue…

But seriously, who is the single person or group on this planet who can turn this situation around, if not you? Get a move on.

June 11, 2010

Still not enough

Filed under: business,marketing — Erik Dobberkau @ 11:33

Marketers have been knowing for ages that it’s cheaper to market to existing customers than acquiring new ones. And there are three factors that help this circumstance:

  • People are lazy.
  • People are afraid.
  • People forget.

It’s the new customers that are put off by (sometimes clever and funny) reports of how customer service is denied, how employees stupidly force policies on customers, all the promises were not kept — it’s all online, available at a single click.
But guess what? That’s still not enough to make all the old customers go away too. And quite ironically, it’s not the fear of disappointment if the alternative fails as well. It’s the fear of the alternative being better, realising one should have tried earlier.

June 9, 2010

At least

Filed under: business,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 09:48

Thinking about yesterday’s post’s last paragraph, it came to my mind that the current justice feels good for only one reason:  “I might have a smaller income, but at least I don’t have to pay as much tax as my boss.” You might have guessed it, the key words here are “at least”.

They are the indicator of a foul compromise, something the lizard brain keeps sending to your consciousness so you don’t take action. “C’mon, it’s not that bad, there’s still one thing to cling to.” And when you think about it, people say it quite often, far too often in fact. “My job is hell, but at least I can pay my bills.” — “My partner spends too little time with me, but at least I have a dog.” and my favourite: “Our business doesn’t make any money, but at least it’s fun.”

In reality, at least is nothing else but a final warning that your compromise has turned out to have more down- than upside — and is on the verge of failing. This is also the reason why salespeople hardly ever say it when they’re pitching to someone. Because the message is: “There is nothing else that makes using this product/upholding the status quo sensible any more. Better try something different.”

And of course, this means putting yourself at risk. Just because you believe you deserve better doesn’t mean it will come to you. The earth is revolving beneath our feet, but we don’t get anywhere unless we move ourselves.

June 8, 2010

Tax marketing

Filed under: marketing,media,politics — Erik Dobberkau @ 10:10

Never having really thought about it before, it occured to me that the marketing of a change of a country’s tax policy is quite a tricky issue, because it clearly shows how people are more afraid of losing something they have than eager to get something they don’t have yet — especially when what they get is a non-bankable idea. But let’s start from the beginning.

As long as I can remember, we’ve been sold on the idea that progressive income tax is just and fair. The strong can and therefore should carry more load, they said. That’s why people with smaller income have been paying less tax than people with big income. Then the strong said, “Wait! We’re the ones who give work to the others, and our factories and means of production depreciate, so politics must make sure we can do this in the future — or else!” And politics did just that, complying well-behaved so the system would survive. They created exceptions and loopholes for the strong and said this is just and fair, because otherwise the economy would be put at risk, and we need a healthy economy to survive and thrive.

Over the years the whole tax system got more and more complicated, which in return meant a lot of jobs for tax consultants, and everyone got used to the year in, year out modifications of tax law, closing old loopholes and creating new ones and so forth. But altogether everyone got used to the way it was and no one really made an effort to change the system. What for? It was just and fair. Or was it?

Enter the (German chancellor’s) financial adviser: “A tax rate of 25% for everybody is just and fair. There is no reason why a CEO should pay 45% tax on earned income and the company owner only 25% tax on unearned income. Plus, there will be no future eceptions and loopholes. And everywhere I speak, this clicks with the audience.” The explanation is of course, when you speak in front of privileged people only (most of them being both CEO and owner at the same time), hardly anyone will refuse. Try to do that when the audience consists of 1% board members and 99% workers, who will very unlikely be happier when you tell them that a tax advantage by working night shifts is cut.

The point is once again not what is, but how it feels. Anyone who can do basic math intellectually knows that same tax for everybody and all exceptions cut is an overall balanced equation — but it doesn’t feel like one. And that’s the problem with marketing the new justice and fairness. At the moment, they don’t feel as good as — never mind better than — the old ones. Who can you sell that to?

(Sidebar — Another whack on a journalists head: If you want an answer, just ask one question about one issue at a time. Asking two or more, you give the interviewee cover to answer none of them. Quote: Journalist: “Many citizens are more than upset that compulsory federal saving might take away their tax benefits: tax-priviliged nightwork, tax-deductible commuting expenses or reduced GST with food, for example. At the same time the government provides billions of Euros in financial aids for other coutries. Is this fair?” — Expert: “The question is, is it legitimate?” — Ouch.)

« Newer Posts — Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress