ideasarehere

February 28, 2010

Art. Now.

Filed under: marketing,media,music — Erik Dobberkau @ 20:08

Sometimes, people who make money with music decide it’s time to stand up for something and use their work to create a major change. Now here’s the punchline: The last time this happened was in 1984, when Harry Belafonte persuaded Ken Kragen to produce a single, the song for which was written by Lionel Ritchie and Michael Jackson. Only a few months before Bob Geldof had done the same in Great Britain. Both songs, We are the world and Do they know it’s Christmas, are larger-than-life art. Not because music is a form of art, but the very idea behind these specific pieces.

They were, and still are, quite rightfully massive successes, not only because they were performed by the most famous singers (and musicians) of their time, but because the ones who created them were so passionate about what they were doing, that you must be deaf not to hear it.

In the meantime there have also been natural disasters like earthquakes in Haiti or Chile, Tsunamis in South East Asia, drought in Africa. The world is still in massive need, maybe more than ever. But it seems that it needs cataclysmic events — only that some folks gather up and re-record a 25-year old piece of music. And today, it’s yet another song. As a person who loves music, it sickens the hell out of me to hear a piece of crap like Artists for Haiti. Who are they trying to kid? One moment I thought “Hey, is that Stephen Hawking singing? No wait — it’s some guy with an autotune and vocoder effect. What the bloody hell??” (Apologies to Mr Hawking.)

This is not art. This is not passionate. This is not authentic. It’s just a scam, a cheap stunt. I’m not buying it. If you are not passionate enough to make this your quest, to put your own sweat and blood into this, I won’t believe your story. Never.

When there are more than 50 artists people who happen to have a gross fortune of more than 1,000,000,000 (yep, that’s one billion) dollars and they decide to make a record that generates, say, 25 cents net profit per copy that could go to charity, and every other American buys one copy, that’s about 40,000,000 dollars going to charity. You’d have 25% more if everyone participating gave 1M like that. But why should they, right?

Art has become really, really scarce nowadays. Which should encourage everyone of us feeling the passionate urge to do art to overcome our inner resistance and start doing it. Now.

February 23, 2010

TV, the Industry, the Web …and us

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,media,music — Erik Dobberkau @ 22:59

Sometimes thinking up a post takes a little longer because you’re trying to come up with (at least) one phrase that sets it apart, make it stand out, and frame it. Check.

The other day I had a conversation about the previous post with a good friend who has been like a mentor for me over the last years. He said this was all good and true, but there’s one thing the Web can’t do but the old alliance can: Make a star. A real star. Someone (or maybe even something) that people will look up to. What they will buy (including merchandise). The Web might be too specialised, too fragmented to build a massive movement.

Two thoughts — First: Industry has designed stuff that’s average so a lot of people would buy it and it would become a success. Aim for the centre and you’ll land a hit. Limit choice and sales go up, because people want to spend money on something. The Web took away the need to adapt, because now you don’t make the most profit from creating average stuff for the masses, but valuable stuff for small groups who are willing to spend disproportionally large amounts of money on their favourites. Or Amazon’s endless shelf space. We don’t need average anymore.
Second: The central (perceived) idea of the Web is that everything is free. Which is why people or incidents can become famous quicker than ever, free spreads faster than anything, gets passed on because people want to be part of it. This is the downside for the industry — once they decide to pick up the idea and monetize it, it’s over. Now it’s not free anymore, people have been robbed of what was “theirs”. It’s quite an impossible task to persuade somebody to give you money for something that has been free until the day before. This is why the “Web Stars” are rarely successful to cash in via selling themselves to the industry. What works, with music for example, is to go on tour and play hundreds of club gigs in venues you can easily fill. If you’ve got millions of hits on the Web, chances are a number of people in every town know you, some will be passionate enough to tell their friends, and presto! Sold out.

TV has a problem. In and of itself, it’s out of date. TV is Nixon, The Gulf War, Golden Girls, Coca Cola. Because this is what TV has been (most of the time) in the last 40 years. Not only TV of course, the whole system mentioned before. Designed to deliver from factory to family. But it also fed another need which is one of the essential human needs: stories. We all need stories, they’re part of our community, our culture. ManU fans thrash the crap out of Leeds fans during the football season, but when England plays Germany they’re brothers in arms. This is because of a story, the need to belong, to identify.

The Web has a place for everyone, but it’s always distant, not personal. And just because a bunch of people who are passionate about something gather on the Web, it doesn’t mean they will inevitably create something that is of value for them or others. Search YouTube for [insert name of your favourite series] for fan videos. You won’t be watching them for long, I reckon.

And this is where the future of TV is (at the moment). They’ve got enough people to come up with ideas, plots, characters, everything you need to create good stories, and what’s more, stories people can easily relate to because they (optionally) include regional aspects. This is something Hollywood can’t do, they must be bigger, louder, fancier than last time, and more average in their stories. When you’re making a TV programme, you don’t have to. You only have to accept that there is no centre any more. Accept that “safe” is gone and “cheap” has been taken by the cluttered Web.

February 22, 2010

Reaping the remains

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,media — Erik Dobberkau @ 12:57

This has been one of the hardest posts for me to write so far, because the topic is quite complex (yet again, very simple), but I thought I better write two posts (here and here) as sort of primer before this one.

If you were running a Commercial TV station, it’s been easy to remember what it’s about, because the name contains the proper order: Commerce first, TV second. That’s how it used to be run until this very day. A number of channels with free programme, because it’s financed by advertisements that interrupt it every few minutes.

This is the story of a Supplier, and quite a good-natured one. Because it’s built around the viewer, and it’s free. Boom. Instant success. And it allowed for perfect vertical integration. You could own the whole production and distribution chain, thus maximise your profits.

And there’s Supplier’s Evil Twin. It takes whatever chunks of content it can get, but they must be cheap, and combines them, held together by ad-glue®. Combine that with its Good Twin and you have an idea what Commercial TV is about.

The reason why this system could exist for more than 25 years (one might say only, compared to the US), is because everyone who was everywhere but before the screen profited from it. TV, ad agencies, all industries. The audience’s benefit was that they got to see things they had never even thought or dreamed of.

But when broadband internet became affordable and computers turned from hi-tech to commodities, the game changed. Now there were even more things no one had ever thought or dreamed of, more clutter that could soak up more ad-glue®, a whole new forest of trees with low-hanging fruit. Ads could be displayed over unlimited time, because they were part of the content from the very beginning (which is not exactly true of course, but when the internet became a mass phenomenon, ads were already everywhere).

So now the TV fruitpickers are about to go out of business, they were to slow to get to the new easy picking grounds. So what are they doing? Instead of seeking excellence, improving their business for long-term sustainability, their CEOs try to satisfy their shareholders with short-term action and lobbyism. What they now want is deregulation, the removal of the chains that restrict the hourly ad allowance. They want an exclusive lifting platform for themselves, because, as they argue, their fruitpicking keeps dozens of other industries alive.

Funny that these people, who laughed at the music industry for their failures ten years ago, now are mobilizing massive forces to persuade politics to change the system in their favor. It’s hard to imagine that they don’t know that they’re in the same situation now, committing the same mistakes, but they prefer to ignore it. Except it’s not really funny, because a politician’s sight hardly goes beyond the next election period, so it’s quite probable they will give in.

February 18, 2010

Facebook Funnel Failure

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,media — Erik Dobberkau @ 15:24

How many users can you reach via Facebook? It’s quite interesting to have a look at the numbers, to see which pages have most fans, and to see how the fan count develops over time. Here are two examples I picked because the numbers are available and both of them help me make my point.

Both are fun ideas, the first one is understandable throughout the world, because almost everybody has heard of Mr Bean and Avatar. So, how many out of 400,000,000 members are fans of a funny idea like this? Less than 2M. In absolute figures, 2,000,000 is quite a number. But it’s less than 1%. Which reminds me of a post of Derek’s. And here’s how the group grew.

Plain to see that the hoopla the idea created wore off pretty quick. But generating 300,000 fans per day is still not bad, isn’t it? Plus, what bosses love to see is a linear chart because it suggests constant growth, which appears to be a good thing. But it tells a smart marketer that the idea is not catching on, because the multiplier in each generation is 1 or less.

And this is an idea that could catch on regionally, quite a hoot at first, but it also doesn’t prevail. Out of 7.2M Facebook members in Germany, no more than 500,000 like this idea enough to become a fan, which makes a share of about 6.7%. Funny to note that on day 12 the page got featured on TV and the press, and you can see no impact. It rather suggests that without this support growth would have declined even further by now. Or maybe because of it.

Compare this to the most popular pages, only two of which have more than 10M fans. And most of them are REALLY BIG names, brands that have been around for years and have worldwide leverage. Now that the competition for attention has been cluttered up on another channel, does it really make sense to squeeze your shtick in there to end up with 200 fans? Besides, they are not really fans, because chances are that they’re not passionate about you and what you do. Why do you think you need to join?

Well, it makes sense to join. Because you still have the opportunity to reach the right people, the people you want. To do so, you really need to sharpen your profile or you won’t cut through. Even people you might love you don’t have all day to keep looking for you. And the passing on of ideas stops sooner than you might have thought.

February 15, 2010

Fetish for the Masses

Filed under: marketing,media — Erik Dobberkau @ 09:33

A cultural magazine programme lately announced “The desire for authenticity is the fetish of our time.” Not only does it prove that the one who made it up has no sense of language, but also no understanding of human nature. Which is why his programme fails and those who understand to satisfy this desire thrive.

The desire for authenticity is not some new fashionable deviation, we’ve passed the point way back when it became the essential need of the majority.

February 10, 2010

Juggling 2.0

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,media,music — Erik Dobberkau @ 21:58

Some years ago, many musicians were very intrigued by the idea of doing business on their own. Booking shows, doing PR work, writing a song, do some HTML homepage programming, CD layout, write another song… The way of spending your time seemed quite stable and reasonable (whatever that may be).

Then came mySpace. And everyone had to get in. New activity: Figuring out how to have your own layout. Individual artist homepages got dumped. MySpace was the place to be. Then came Facebook. MySpace was declining, everybody went on to create their artist pages on Facebook, allowing for more connections but a less individual look. But hey, content matters, right? Then came Twitter. No look at all, no content. Just… another place to waste your time, figuring out what to say in 140 characters. But you had to have it. Totally connected. Boiling point. And now: Google Buzz! Artists collapsing all over the place.

They start complaining (quite rightfully) that they cannot handle all these connections without spending so much time on them that they practically don’t creeate music anymore. Mission failed.

Here’s my advice: Get off mySpace, it’s no use but a dead end. Have a blog, on Typepad, WordPress, Blogger or whichever you prefer. Just select a theme you like and add your images. Set up a bit.ly account that hooks into your Twitter account and automatically shortens the links you post. Go to a service like twitterfeed.com which hooks into your blog’s RSS feed and automatically posts to Facebook, Twitter and whatever they support. If you’re using Gmail, Google Buzz is now built in and can automatically re-post your Twitter tweets (but not vice versa). There. All done. Now go make some music. The web takes care of itself.

December 18, 2009

Who’s watching?

Filed under: media — Erik Dobberkau @ 00:45

Coming back to the topic of public broadcasters looking for new ways to finance their organizations, the sparse discussion on the topic focuses on the wrong end. Here’s why: (in Germany but other coutries too) Public TV exists to ensure the availability of neutral information, or the multitude of sources of information, because Freedom of Information is a Constitutional Right. They are ordered by the public (or rather the legislator) to exist. The government must not interfere (which prohibits funding by taxes, because that could be a reprisal — and yet they do interfere, because they have delegates in all relevant commitees). What the whole current discussion boils down to: What legal base should the charge have that an individual (or a household? how about businesses?) has to pay? And how to charge – for each device or per adult or…? All in an effort to get the maximum justifiable amount of cash. But this discussion omits one important point: relevance due to bandwidth.

On traditional broadcast media (TV and radio) bandwidth is technically limited, so there is only room for a limited number of channels. Even on satellite, because compared to the internet with millions of channels available, 500+ channels on satellite is a puny number. In this old environment, Public TV still plays an important role, because they use quite a lot of bandwith due to their numerous amount of channels. Which means the likelihood of you watching or listening to one of their programmes is quite high.

Then came internet.
And what these people don’t get is that on this “convergent platform” as they call it, their relevance has shrunk to close to zero. The old justification was “when you have a radio, you have to pay because you can use it, whether you really do it or not” doesn’t apply on the net. Because of two reasons: a. on the radio, the chance of dialing in to one of their programmes is 80+% (on antenna TV 100% in rural regions, less in the cities and on cable). They certainly wish it were that high online. But it isn’t, and because of that, their demands for charges on computers and cellphones are not only ridiculous but also immoral. b. On the web, they cannot fulfil their duty of delivering neutral information. This is because the web by its nature is a free medium, so it naturally breeds various free information. The argument of “historically trusted source of hi-quality journalism” has no relevance here. And what’s more, should anybody ever decide to filter information or commit censorship, what’s to stop them from cutting of these “trusted sources” in the first place?

They do not understand that the game on the web has entirely different rules, and they cannot change them to work in their favour. But they’re also not willing to change their system, which makes it very difficult for them to cash in just because they’re available. So instead of reinventing their business (ouch the pain!) it’s much easier to try to use their political allies to turn democracy on its head.

December 10, 2009

Basic Viral Checklist

Filed under: media — Erik Dobberkau @ 15:44

Currently revisiting Seth Godin’s Permission Marketing, it came clear to me that you can’t help but smile about the illiteracy of today’s marketing departments, especially when trying to come up with something viral. Over the last decade there are so many examples of “this is how you do it” (still outnumbered by “this is how you should NEVER EVER do it”), that everybody could easily come up with a checklist of no-gos, such as:

  • mentioning your brand slogan-wise
  • including statements that boil down to “this thing is sooo average, you have to like it” (subtext: “because we spent sooo many hours tweaking it down from being very edgy to so-so”)
  • having a “professional look” (like shot on film or high def camera, proper (=boring) lighting etc.), but not being at the edge of what’s possible in ANY direction.

Well, basically everything that makes a TV ad the way we know it ever since. Once again, the web is not another TV channel where your message can be forced onto the viewer and they keep their mouths shut. On the web, the best that can happen to you if someone dislikes your interruption, is clicking it away. Far worse is when they decide to spread the word that you suck big time and are boring and they wish you’d rot in some nasty place. They are very likely to get more leverage than you.

December 9, 2009

Money for Nothing

Filed under: media — Erik Dobberkau @ 13:14

Recent reports have said that by next year people in Germany will have to pay for using their computers no matter what. Behind this outrageous plan are the states’ broadcasting offices (of which there are 9, because it is federally organized — yep, that’s a major money drain nowadays). So, ironically enough, after having been ordered by court to limit their online activity, these organizations now try to charge fees for something they are not fully allowed to offer. Think about that for a sec.

In most other European countries, people are only to pay for TVs and radios. Sticking to this system has some sense, but what it does under the hood is not always clear and by far not to understand for everybody. Part of it is for maintaining the technical broadcast infrastructure, although analog broadcasting is almost no more used for TV. But cable and satellite are not operated by the public TV stations, and the telephone wires certainly not! Combine these two conclusions (there are some more, but that’s something to cover later), and (if you’re affected by this issue) ask yourself if you’re really gonna take this one.

« Newer Posts

Powered by WordPress