ideasarehere

April 19, 2011

Different Interests

Filed under: business,creativity,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 06:23

Seth Godin wrote a few days ago student debt has reached  new record in the US, now totalling at about one trillion dollars, which equals 10 million people with $100,000 of debt each. There are some folks who argue spending this money is an investment like a mortgage on your future home, because currently a college graduate earns about $20,000 more per year than someone who has only completed high school, but I think that’s not going to last because of the erosion of all these certificates. However, my point is an entirely different one.

Everyone, no matter what age, has an idea what their life should be like in the future, and for most of us it’s one where we’re better off than today (whatever that may mean). And some of us will be the one who come up with ideas that will completely change our lives. And some of these people are not going have these great ideas in 5 years, but right now. The problem is, no one is listening to them. Because they aren’t experts. What do these greenhorns know? And even if they could put their idea to work, how would they know how to run a company that commercialises the idea? No, way too risky, thinks the man on the opposite side of the bank teller.

The problem with banks is not only that they (still) misjudge credit risks, it’s even worse: this is their purpose. What’s more valuable: Someone who owes you $50,000 in startup credit who can pay it back within two years, or someone who owes you $100,000 for their degree at first, then $100,000 more for their new home, then $60,000 more for a car and so forth? Their interest is to make money by leading people through a debt curve which has been proven to work for the bank, but nothing else.

Young people are trying to find their way into their best future, but obviously it doesn’t lead through a bank’s portal. Someone who has an idea is most likely better off to find a supportive venture capitalist, even if it requires flying to Silicon Valley or wherever that person may be located. To believe they could buy an expert status with the degree of a well-known institution might end up with someone else having the idea too and turning it into reality before them. Then what?

Then comes the insight that ideas and expertise are two different pairs of shoes, interacting but not interdependent, and one can’t replace the other. And there also comes the (sometimes long) wait for the next idea.

April 18, 2011

Being an Expert

Filed under: business,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 07:22

Credibility is in a way related to demonstrated success, which in our minds is transformed to expertise. When somebody does something well, we say, she must know a great deal about this. That’s why it’s easier for people to hire freelancers they’ve been working with before with (at least) satisfactory results. But whenever there’s a new face showing up, we’re sceptical. And for these new faces it’s very hard to prove their expertise, and it’s getting harder day by day. Just because they’ve done a good job for somebody else there’s no guarantee they’ll do a good one for us, because our situation is different, and there are dozens of other reasons easily made up to hesitate.

Thing is, being an expert has not become easier. How’s that?
In the end, it comes down to a simple formula:

Expertise = amount of knowledge in a particular field ÷ availability of this knowledge.

It’s as simple as that. In areas that have been explored for long and by a lot of people, as economics, there is a lot of knowledge around, giving a lot of people the idea that just because they know something, they’re semi-experts, and they can learn the rest from Wikipedia. Time is not a critical factor because it doesn’t matter how fast you reach the boundaries of an area. So in economics we have both a lot of knowledge as well as good access to it, which makes the former the critical factor. In other areas, which are more at the fringes of awareness or imagination for the most of us, the situation is different: There might be little knowledge (some things you can learn in an hour), but the availability might be little too, so it’s access that’s the critical factor.

But in the end, repeatedly demonstrated success outguns every bookshelf or diploma-decorated wall.

March 11, 2011

Storytelling, Inspiration, Expectation

Filed under: business,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 08:24

A very good friend of mine has decided “Leave a message after the beep” would not do for his phone mailbox. His is “After the beep, tell me something I don’t know yet.” Isn’t that how all of us are — not necessarily being aware of it — going through life? Looking for inspiration, new insight? The problem is, I don’t know what you know yet. And this is something that  makes it sometimes very difficult to tell a story that has the same persuasiveness to everyone.

Noreena Hertz has a TED talk during which she argues that experts are not infallible and we need to make more decisions on our own. The Domino Project, Seth Godins latest publishing venture, has a series of features on certain people telling their stories and what supposedly makes them special. And these are just two examples of stories that didn’t resonate with me. I wasn’t like “Wow, this is great, I must tell my friends!”, it was more like “I wonder what kind of world you’re living in.” And it’s not because it was a bad or badly told story, but it just didn’t cross the chasm between my expectation and what was actually delivered. This is enforced by the standard that has been set, sometimes by the people themselves. I do expect TED talks to be remarkable, an I do expect Seth Godin to come up with a different view on whatever each time he posts.

And sometimes, it really works. Remember Jay O’Callahan? Or (the obvious example) Ken Robinson? All of the people I talked about this with were deeply impressed by those speeches. Obviously there wasn’t such a great level of expectation at work, and expectation, it seems, puts us at defense, where we are not open to a certain degree. Which then bears the risk that we’re missing that one tiny bit of inspiration that lies in every story, but not always it’s plain to see. My latest example is as follows:

After reading the story of Laurie Davis on SxSW Pokes (the unmodest tone of which is explicable by the fact that all participants write the stories themselves, and they might be published unedited), when the annoyance about wasting two minutes of my precious morning’s time was gone (“Duh, no inspiration! Useless bravado!”), it occured to me that the point I made in an earlier post obviously isn’t off. The paraphrase I found today is “Business is taking advantage of other people’s problems”, not meaning to hurt them on top of their problem, but benefitting yourself by solving their problem (through, say, getting paid by them). To examine a business idea this might come in handy by asking “On a per-person level, is that a problem big enough, pressing enough (in time and/or emotional respect) that people are likely to pay to have it solved? And how many are there?”

Sometimes, it seems, not the facts that we know make the difference, but the connections in between, and what happens in the aftermath of telling the story that incorporates these facts, and this is something you have little control over. But telling a good story or telling a story well won’t hurt either.

February 7, 2011

Chances

Filed under: business,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 20:12

Whenever you’re offered a chance that requires you to wait, not to argue or any other form of being passive, it’s not a chance. It might be one for the one who’s giving you this “friendly advice”, but not for you.

A real chance is an occassion when you have to be active, sometimes exceed your limits and putting something that’s perceived as right or valuable as of now at risk, so something better can be achieved.

January 23, 2011

The 3 Most Important Things To Do

Filed under: business,creativity,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 13:12

It just came to me as a strike of genius when writing an e-mail to a friend. They’re in no particular order, because they’re somewhat interdependent.

  • Enable. The How-To.
  • Inspire. The What. The Why.
  • Permit. This is often forgotten. The “it’s okay to fail, as long as you keep on trying. Go ahead.”

January 18, 2011

Fooled by the Status Quo

Filed under: business,internet,media,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 00:58

It’s always amazing how one’s imagination is being fooled by the status quo though the own memory should tell otherwise. When Wikipedia celebrated thier 10-year anniversary three days ago, I was thinking back when I actually started using it. In 2001 I didn’t — and it’s worth noting it’s the same year I started using that new search engine called Google. It occured to me that when writing my diploma thesis on analogue audio compressor circuitry design and implementation in 2002, finding mere bits of information was actually work that was not too far from the days when you had to go to the library and skim through boxes of index cards. The whole thing just went off well because a fellow student was writing his thesis on EQ design so we could update each other about our latest findings.

Just a few years later, maybe in early 2005, I was using Wikipedia to pull together a script for my students’ electronics lecture, just as an expanded appendix for all the stuff I couldn’t cover in detail because the lecture was quite dense already. Only 4 years after its birth, Wikipedia had become the go-to resource for every geek topic, not to mention the thousands of other sites that had spawned up on stuff like audio circuitry. But what was funny back then is that most of them still referenced the same sources that we had to dig out years before.

Today, more or less everybody is online, be it as a consumer or content creator, but you better not assume that the absolute number of “web literates” has increased proportionally. In this is becoming a problem, because at some point, we’re passing it on to the next generation. According to an interview with two media experts published in the German magazine “Der Spiegel”, there is a shocking deficiency in media competence among teachers, and as they point out, it is the responsibility of schools to educate the kids in the why and how of media, because it’s the only place where all of these kids go — and you don’t know how well-informed their parents are in terms of Web and so forth.

The real problem is of course not media but responsibility, and it’s hard to teach responsibility because it’s rather something you learn. The digital era has a massive downside compared to the glory days before it: As Google put it, the Web doesn’t forget. People do. If you broke a window, it’d be a shock at first, you’d get punished, and some years later you’d have a funny story to tell. I don’t want to spread paranoia here, but in absence of a better excuse a digital record of you having smashed a window in your child days might serve as an unspoken reason why you’re not getting a job. So it may well mean the chance of anyone getting a second chance (to do better) will go down, just because you’re the one who, as is anybody on one subject or the other. The Web is no good place to start when you haven’t learned the analogue model. The only advantage we have today is that we still have analogue models, because there a only few web services that don’t have a real world counterpart.

On the other hand, it’s hard to draw a line in terms of when available information is to be used fairly. When a government can use information published on WikiLeaks to prosecute tax evaders — no matter if this information was obtained legally or not, it’s available now, and it’s hard to argument that one shouldn’t use it to enforce the law — it seems unfit to force an employer to not consider dubious information they got about their job candidates. It’s again a question of responsibility. And as we know, when faced with the opportunity, most people will prefer to get rid of it instead of taking some more, something they learned along the way too. Everything scales, you just need enough iterations to make a small difference to yield a large result. It actually works both ways. That’s why Wikipedia won.

January 3, 2011

Coming in Second

Filed under: business,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 21:01

There are two ways of looking at competitive settings: One has it that you either win or don’t win, and numerous people interpret the latter as losing. Which is why they tend to be dissatisfied quite often, because every time they come in second, no matter if there are only two or a thousand more competitors, they feel they have lost.

The other way means to look at the way things are: No matter how many competitors there are, you only “lose” compared to those who come in before you. Which makes coming in second a success more often than not.

The point is that focusing on the downside of your results rarely leads to improvement because it takes away your verve because you feel you’re still too weak, not good enough, a dilettante, which in result makes you even more afraid and hesitant the next time you’re facing the challenge — whereas focusing on the upside makes it easy to tackle the points where you can improve, because you feel you’re already good, but not the best. Not yet. But maybe next time, which you are looking forward to.

October 25, 2010

Things learned at TEDx

Filed under: business,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 11:52

Erik Dobberkau's TEDx RheinNeckar badgeLast Saturday I had the pleasure of attending TEDx RheinNeckar, my first TED-related live event ever, and here are some things that came to my mind during and after it.

The organizers did a great job, really, I must say it was one of the best events I’ve been to so far. Everyone was to wear the depicted badge around their neck so people would immediately know your name. One excellent detail: At the bottom it had a section “Talk to me about:” that you could fill out yourself. Unfortunately not a lot of people did, because for those who did it turned out to be a real conversation starter during the breaks. More than half of the guests were students from the local university, a lot of them not having written anything on their cards, and they flocked in their peer groups as they would do on any given day, instead of starting talking with a complete stranger, building relationships and so forth.

Something that seriously bothered me was the whole PA thing. Obviously there was no professional sound technician present, resulting in some minor technical hiccoughs, but what was also optically annoying was the microphones they were using, because these were really huge headsets. Okay, the decent small and skin-tone one are more expensive to buy, but when you rent the whole thing I don’t believe it’s much of a cost difference, but a huge difference in visual appearance. And you always want your speakers to look as good as possible, right?

Speaking of who I have to mention that a large portion of the speakers also have books published, which were also on display in the back of the room, and the speakers would sign them and so forth. Now, since the claim of TED is “Ideas worth spreading”, guess what I think people should do? Right, get their ideas out! So I wondered why nobody gave away their book for free or at a discount price (at least it was not announced) — which again results in telling myself the story that maybe these people are not so much interested in spreading their (partly counterfeit) ideas as they’re interested in making a buck.

Speaking of stories, I learned a very valuable lesson in the first session called “People and Economy”. Picture this: You have a great topic to talk about, you’re a great presenter, but still you don’t succeed all the way at making an impression. How’s that? Two things: Keep in mind that you have to be authentic. Don’t give the impression of putting yourself over your topic. Show humility. The other thing: If your talk covers an interrelated topic, it’s almost a sure bet that in an audience of more than 200 people there are some who either already know what you’re talking about or know even more or more precise about one single aspect you’re just scratching on the surface. That’s not a good combination with the posture of “I know I’m a good presenter”. And one more thing which I touched on, but important enough to repeat: Show humility. Not one of the speakers started with “Thank you, glad to be here” — a shame. And don’t sell your organization or product unless it’s charity. Organizers, please don’t invite these people. There are enough trade shows out there.

And the last thing I want to talk about is a personal comment on one the the stories from the first section. The talk was about change leadership, and the speaker suggested that a leader has to set an example to his followers, giving the example of the CEO of a company should not only cut costs by cutting on staff expenses, but set an example by replacing his Mercedes by a VW Golf, so employees would see “Look, even the boss is saving, that’s how serious the thing is”. The only problem with this idea is that not only employees start telling this story, but everyone who sees what’s going on. What happens is that a potential customer is less likely to do business with someone who’s looking like he’s on the direct way out of it. Instead, the thing to do is to create a story that shines a good light on what you’re doing. So if you buy a Prius or some other Hybrid, you can start telling the story of raising eco-awareness and that you’re thinking about replacing your whole car fleet with Hybrids, but since this is a major investment and you want to make sure your staff gets a high quality car, you’re testing it yourself. Now how does that sound?

September 17, 2010

The Problem with No Problems

Filed under: business,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 10:27

Most people complain about the amount of problems they have. At work, with their spouse, their kids, their neighbours, at their club. So the natural reaction seems to avoid problems by circumventing them. And some people have mastered this to a point where they can say “I don’t have any problems.” At the same time they wonder why they feel a lack of purpose, the dullness that somehow has creeped into their lives.

Not having any problems is the worst that can happen to you, because you’re not finding solutions, hence you’re not creating value. The people who create the most value, be it for business or personal, are those who seek out problems. No problems, no opportunities.

July 30, 2010

Obligated, not entitled

Filed under: business,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 19:20

Some days ago I read on an Australian blog the Small and Medium Enterprises were desperately looking for leaders. Not only those who pop in, give a speech or workshop and off they go, but who actually do lead by making things happen where they need to.

Now what most people mean when they cry out this way is “I need someone from a high-profile university to make my problems go away”. Because that’s what they’re looking for when you read their job ads. Now I cannot prove that an MBA graduate were there wrong kind of person for this. But I can prove that there’s a better way to pre-select. I don’t know about every country’s anti-discrimination laws, but in general what you want to do is have people send a full photo, not just portrait, so you can examine their posture. I don’t mean if their spine is deformed or one leg is longer than the other. I mean the way they present themselves, which resembles the way they conceive of themselves. As the saying goes, more than a thousand words.

What brought me to this conclusion was a number of photographs I saw on the web the other day. On each there was the same group of university students and grads who run a sort of business consulting agency. What all of these photos were yelling at me was that these young people felt entitled to be offered only the best jobs. Which to me was quite disconcerting, for a number of reasons.

You don’t get to go to a university because you’re extremly brilliant (those who are go there at 12, so anyone who’s not 12 when they commence university might correct their self image in that respect). You get to go to a university because you’re good at school, which again is not a product of your intelligence but how good you are at meeting expectations and working to spec. And university is an extension of this, only the bar is raised by blurring the spec so you have to figure out what it is and then try to do a point landing. I’m always impressed by the insignificance of theses that grants students an academic title. The only reason they occupy a hundred pages to make a no more point than a blog post is footnotes and the bibliography, the requirements of scientific research.

[When I was in my first semester studying business information technology, the math professor started her first lecture by prompting a complex equation to the wall “See, that’s what you will know how to calculate by the end of the semester.” Back then, had I had the wit I have today, I’d have asked her how this will help us significantly improve the world, exactly. I doubt it would have enabled anyone to show more initiative.]

And the point is: a better education is not an entitlement to a better job. It is an obligation to put all you know and can do to a good use and the benefit of all. Nothing less. Education is the prerequisite that enables you to create value that people will eventually pay for. Nothing more. Someone with no education can only contribute labour (in the workplace), while educated people can organize and get stuff moving. But they don’t, because they feel and believe they’re getting paid merely for showing up. After all, they’re entitled to this because of all they’ve been doing to get there, right?

So the question for you becomes: Is this the kind of person who you believe to lead your company to a better future? Or are you looking for someone who’s hungry and humble too?

« Newer Posts — Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress