ideasarehere

July 21, 2010

Solution vs. Engagement

Filed under: creativity,internet,marketing,personal — Erik Dobberkau @ 14:25

It’s funny that I’m now kind of hooked to this whole topic of engagement, and this might be just a temporal selective perception issue, but as long as it lasts, it seems sensible to make use of it to get a different perspective on our lives.

Today, a friend called out for help on formatting his Master Thesis, and I thought this would be an easy-to-fix issue, so I posted a link to a tutorial on the web. As it turns out, it didn’t fix his problem. So I asked him to send his document, and because it took a little longer, I tried to replicate the issue on my computer, and got back to him after 10 minutes with a solution which worked, and we were both happy. (His file came in 20 mins later. Praise email.)

The important point is, not only was he happy that his problem was solved, but also that someone had spend their time to make this happen. If he had searched a little more, I’m sure he’d have found a solution on the web himself, or he’d have gotten some more links from people who’d have cared a little. But in the end, the value is the personal interaction. We often tend to forget that solutions (as well as problems) don’t exist by themselves — they’re being created by real people. And the value lies in the creation process, not in its outcome.

That’s why a solution is never as valuable as the engagement that led to it.

July 20, 2010

Outcome of an Experiment

Filed under: internet — Erik Dobberkau @ 13:50

Five days ago, as promised, I asked my Facebook peers (about 160 people) to post an important question. If all that people need is a concrete opportunity this would suffice to activate their latent need for expression, I thought. Any bets?

Guess what, nothing happened. Well, not quite. I had prepared myself for some mockery and the like, but even that didn’t happen. Silence.

And once again, the question becomes: Why don’t people engage? Now we’ve successfully eliminated the lack of opportunity as sole explanation, what else is there?

  • Personal reasons: Why should they respond to someone who’s not a leader in that field or at all in their opinion? Reversing that argument uncovers that people might respond to a leader’s question only because she’s a leader, not because people genuinely want to.
  • Reward: There was nothing in it for them. Or not enough that was plain to see.
  • Timing: The question came in on Thursday, but they had all their important questions sorted out by Wednesday. You bet.
  • Fear. Responding to someone asking you to post an important question is considered as serious exposure rather than taking the opportunity to get something going.

The problem is, you cant’t really find out. When people are not willing to ask the question itself, it’s hard to believe they are more willing to tell you the reason for their behavior (most of them wouldn’t know anyway). All you can to is consider this circumstance. Trying to overcome the three real obstacles at once is hardly possible without ridiculing yourself. Ask any advertiser about this and brace yourself for an hour-long lament.

Yet there was one response (the only one) that made me think enough to write a single post about it in the next few days.

July 15, 2010

Engagement (and what is not)

Filed under: internet,media — Erik Dobberkau @ 09:11

The liner notes to Hugh’s drawing have it. Now it’s engagement. Just having finished Clay Shirky’s “Cognitive Surplus” , I wondered why it is that, despite the fact it being easier than ever before, people do not engage in meaningful conversation, supporting a cause or starting their own movement. And the answer is quite simple (again): fear.

In a world where people are connected 24/7, it is technically easy to find something you care about. What hinders the engagement is the inconvenience of the process, and more important, the risk you’re putting yourself at. Risk in terms of reputation. As Chris Anderson points out in “Free!”, reputation is something that people are very keen on especially in online social networks. In this context, for some people virtualization has not brought more freedom but more restraints, because they submit themselves to peer pressure not only in the workplace or in private, but since they usually have the same peers online they are now feeling (and sometimes being) watched continuously.

The other important issue is (in)convenience. Most people who have grown up without the Internet are still in a consumer mindset today. They still have the notion of the web being an extension of traditional media, a circumstance which traditional media is still enforcing on their web sites. With their online content being just a repetition of the broadcast or the print, they keep pushing back their visitors to the traditional channels, be it the TV screen or the newspaper stand. They don’t want people to engage online, because everone who does is one consumer lost. But they don’t have to worry, because people act the way they’ve been trained to, they consume web pages. Clicking a “Like” button is not engagement. Re-posting privacy warnings on Facebook isn’t either.

Engagement generates long-term value, and long-term value is the enemy of consumption, because it relies on immediate decay of value after purchase, which doesn’t necessarily have to include a monetary transaction (it does, but that’s a hidden one between the provider and a third party, say an advertiser). And once people figure out something has no long-term value, they stop supporting it. You can see this when we revisit the Pretzel vs. Tokio Hotel fad: 5 months later, the Pretzel group now has about 644,000 members (and remember, they got 500,000 within their first 15 days of existence), whereas the Tokio Hotel fan group now has more than 650,000 . Once again, the reason behind this is quite obvious: Being the fan of an artist has a long-term value, what happens here is the prerequisite to engagement: a tribe is growing, so now whoever is inside this tribe has an organized platform to start engagement. On the other hand, being the fan of a pretzel is fun for the moment, and the inevitable media hype rewards ervery member with the satisfaction of having been part of it, but no more. This is not a tribe, because no one seriously cares about the reason the have gathered for — this is consumption.

I’ll do an experiment today: I’ll ask people to post an important question, on Facebook. I’m curious to see what happens if you ask people to do something instead of waiting for something to happen. Results coming soon.

June 23, 2010

Differentiate

Filed under: business,creativity,internet,marketing — Erik Dobberkau @ 16:08

The other day I was visiting a couple of web sites of media production companies, and what you notice pretty soon is that they all look the same. Not literally of course, some designs are fancier than others, but the overall structure of the sites are very much the same. Which raises the question of why that is. And the answer is: That’s how it has to be. Not for me, but the one who had to decide how the page should be set up thought exactly this. And of course he got there by looking at the competition’s web page. And as always, the first one to achieve [whatever] sets the bar for the next in line. That’s how a common understanding or notion of anything is created: silent agreement and the fear of probably being ridiculed for standing out.

The obvious thing to do is to be completely different. People visiting your corporate web site do it for only one out of two reasons: they either want to buy or they want to be hired. They don’t really want to look at fancy photos of your staff. They don’t want to read pretentious online resumés. Both of these are exclusion criteria. It’s much easier to say “I don’t like how they look” or “they’re too old” or “they’re too young”. None of this information is intruiging in some way to make me buy your stuff. Neither is a job description for a creative professional that reads like a classified ad for a garbage picker’s job (but of course expecting the candidates to submit outstanding samples of work).

So what to do? It’s dead simple. Give your visitors a vivid experience. Have a video for customers and people looking for jobs. If you want to be on screen, be on screen! Talk to them. Say how happy you are that they’re here and give them the tour. Be real. Be tangible. Have one video for customers and one for job seekers. Both care about different aspects of your business and need different information. And for the job seekers, give them an actual task. Ad agencies have been doing this for long, almost every major agency has some sort of copy test available online that challenges applicants to come up with great ideas. Why not do this for designers or editors or even bakers as well? This helps you a lot more analyzing their future potential instead of their past. Maybe they just worked on silly projects that never challenged them to unfold their potential — do you want to do the same by turning them down up front? That’s what you do if you just read resumés.

So if you want to be as different as you claim in your copy, show it to everyone. Showing that you care is more than enough for starters.

May 12, 2010

Journalists are marketers too

Filed under: current affairs,internet,marketing — Erik Dobberkau @ 11:27

Over the last few years the discussion about the future of journalism has been going back and forth, going in circles, going nowhere. I’m not even starting to get in there now, my point is an entirely different one.

A friend pointed me to the latest excess of this topic:
Some days ago, a German blogger wrote a post about how she thought about journalism and its future. The way she wrote was sympathetic you-and-me eye-level. A few days later, she adressed  two newspapers who printed her letter. The difference was that with the change of the medium her tonality changed too. It had this teaching, patronizing, “I’m gonna tell you something” touch. Enter the media expert: The researcher from some university put in all his sweat so it became clear that the 57-year old pro out-argues the 22-year old amateur. But in the end, none of them had an answer.

What surfaces here is that journalism does not have a content problem, it has a marketing problem.

First, what publishers do is fill the gaps between the ads in their papers. Ads don’t make as much money as yesterday, hence to get content as cheap as possible, they prefer news agency and press releases over individually researched relevant articles.

Second, the old media (papers, radio, TV) is too slow. When they pick up a piece of news, so do thousands of others at the same time. And while a journalist is typing his article, Twitter, Facebook and the watercooler gang spread it with far more velocity. When the paper is out the next morning, hot news has frozen to death.

Third, as we can see in recent current affairs, there’s a tremendous shift of what matters to people — and they are who journalists should believe they’re working for.

Fourth, a lot of journalists have an outdated idea of what their job is. Especially when it comes to writing, I am totally pissed off by the pretentious tone you hit upon in every paper that deems itself a piece of “quality journalism”. Here’s the point: The paper is not a stage to get on and pretend cleverness by using educated words (and to fail miserably at coining terms believed to earn a Pulitzer). A shroud of intellectualism is no proof of validity. It is possible to explain complex topics in simple words that deliver every piece of information, meet your readers on eye-level, not patronizing them. Every other approach loses effectivity because if your readership is as clever or cleverer (or educated) than you, they might think “What a puff-up! Who’s he trying to impress other than himself?” — and if they’re less clever, they’ll turn away because they don’t understand the language you’re speaking.

Fifth, the chances of making a buck from something that is also available for free are getting smaller and smaller. This is only fair. If there are people who are passionate about politics, celebrities or whatever there is in a paper, the best what can happen is they share their passion for free by providing high value information on their blogs — and if there are people who are into that as well, they can subscribe for updates via RSS or email, they can get in touch via Facebook or Twitter and engage in comment discussions.  I don’t share the media expert’s idea that people don’t know what they want to know. I think they don’t know where to go to find what they care about in a convenient way. With billions of web pages out there this is no surprise. Enter the power of referrals and links. And of course this is scary for journalists, because they’re confronted with the fact there are millions of extremly clever people out there, who don’t have to write an article in time or depend on making money with their writing, so they can put more effort in deliberately, which may result in a better product.

Sixth… I forgot about number six.

[Update:
Seventh, there is a common notion, even a legal one, that there must be journalism in order to protect democracy. My guess is when the fathers of our constitution thought up the public obligation, they would never have thought there would be so much information that people would stop listening, rendering the argument obsolete. (Think about the irony that the ones privileged by this law try to cut the underlying law (i.e. freedom of speech) for everybody else (i.e. bloggers) because it’s ruining their business model.)  They also thought that people care about the truth. They don’t. People care about what they believe. ]

Conclusion. We have more ways of communicating and spreading ideas than ever before. The old monopolies are gone. So are some of the truths and common wisdom related to them. What matters now is honesty, consistency and passion.

Trying to persuade a government of whatever dimension to uphold yesterday’s status quo will kill business in the long run too, so better invest the same amount of energy to build a business for the future. Even if that means going out of the old business.

May 6, 2010

Where’s the extra?

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,music — Erik Dobberkau @ 06:10

The night I wrote about the Axis of Awesome phenomenon, I also purchased the ‘Kids’ cover by The Ooks of Hazzard because I liked the video on YouTube and I thought 99 cents was not too much of an expense.

It turns out that the single you pay for is the same recording as on the video you get for free. Once more I have to admit that my personal standards do not resemble the zeitgeist in terms of music releases, as it seems. The crucial point is that when making the purchase I expected an extra, the Free Prize inside. Otherwise I would have downloaded the audio part from the video for free.

That’s how you keep the interaction going. Not only by trading something for money, but by putting in a remarkable extra that motivates your customers to tell their friends. It doesn’t have to be expensive but worth talking about. This also applies for transactions that are not about money. By reading this blog you trade time and attention for information and entertainment. But does it contain the extra you expect so you go and tell a friend? Your feedback is most welcome.

May 5, 2010

Auto-clutter

Filed under: internet — Erik Dobberkau @ 10:16

Until this morning I thought you could separate what’s available on the web in two categories: Useful information and clutter. It turns out there’s a third category: auto-clutter. Just by using the term “coffee break syndrome” in the last post, an automatic system on a completely unrelated page generated a pingback (which is basically a link from one blog post to another, be it the same blog or a different one). So I checked back and found out it’s a page about coffee pods (these little plastic cups with concentrated coffee that you put in a machine and get a cuppa). What the heck? It’s because the automatic tracking system is looking for terms like “coffee break” all over the web and generates links to them. I wonder if that’s any good to drive traffic? Maybe. But conversion? Less likely. But it’s free, right? Gotcha. No expense, no thinking if it makes sense.

April 30, 2010

Bite-sized high impact mentoring

Filed under: business,internet,marketing,personal,video — Erik Dobberkau @ 11:06

Robin Dickinson, who is the brother of Motionworks artist John Dickinson, runs a business development company called radsmarts. Not only does he this name justice by what he does every day, he also has a valuable series of short mentoring video clips on his page. Terrific. Thanks Rob!

April 27, 2010

Misconception

Filed under: internet,marketing,music — Erik Dobberkau @ 06:00

This is gonna be a long one. Just so you don’t say I didn’t tell you in the first place.

Last week the online issue of the renowned German magazine “Der Spiegel” released an article titled “The Internet – a poorhouse for musicians” based on this original blog post. Did I say based on? I meant it’s a translation, sorry. A poor one too. As I pointed out before, this article too suffers from the very same disease — it looks like its author spent more time finding an edgy headline rather than substantial information to underline the points made by the original author — or to counter them. What for? After all, he’s a journalist, and if he doesn’t understand what he’s talking about, how could anyone else? But that’s not my point today. I want to talk about what’s mentioned in the original article.

As self-pitiful as this article sounds, it does contain correct information. It’s just a matter of how you interpret it, i.e. what actions you deem necessary as a result. The majority of musicians have correctly concluded that trying to make your living exclusively as a recording artist doesn’t work anymore. And quite correctly, the new ways of distribution are not as profitable as the old ones used to be. By the way, colourful as the chart looks, it’s set up the wrong way. The intention is to show that you have to sell more units of your music when you go digital or streaming to achieve the minimum US income, but the author forgot that the common notion with pleasant colours is, as far as I go, “bigger is better”. In fact, the chart should be upside down, displaying the CD as the medium with the best (i.e. biggest) margin, and streaming the least — or use a warning colour and leave it as it is. Just a sidebar, in case should you be preparing a presentation on a similar issue.

The conclusion was that it’s close to impossible for a non-famous artist to sell a number of downloads or streams that comes even close to these figures. I agree. But my second conclusion from this is different: If the profit is that small, there’s no point in charging a fee anyway. Quite the opposite: A fee is the only reason for someone getting in touch with new stuff for the first time not to try it. After all, there’s enough other artists out there who are good enough, so why stick with those who charge for a product that is free with others?

The intellectual problem for most self-dependent musicians is that they’re being confronted with a real market. This market has 3 simple basic rules:

  • Premium products will sell for premium prices.
  • Average products will only sell for below-average prices.
  • The product life cycle has been drastically shortened.

It’s the Long Tail in action. This is because the conditions to enter the market have been zeroed out. Way back you needed to take extreme effort to get your music to the market, but all the gatekeepers and bottlenecks have been bypassed. You don’t have to please an A&R to be permitted to make a record that will be played on the radio and shipped to stores worldwide any more. Today there are no more physical shops (yes there are, but their number has dramatically decreased), but an infinite number of shops online, most of them selling non-physical goods, that is downloads, and tons of services who want to help you to get you stuff to the market.

Musicians have to get used to the fact that there is no centre anymore. No sure shot. Joe Average has ceased to exist. But what is there is a tiny fraction of people willing to pay a premium for something they are passionate about. This may not seem profitable at first glance, but it is. Mass production and selling a lot for cheap is over. What’s the difference between selling 10,000 records with a $1 margin and 400 records with a $25 margin? The ones who buy it. They are more valueable customers. They care. Which in return burdens the artist to care about them. That’s another thing that scares quite a number of artists. When you decide not to target consumers but (yet to become) fans, it’s not a single transaction any more, it’s the beginning of a relationship. It’s not an anonymous mob you’re dealing with, but real people, individuals who want to be treated with respect and dignity. Which is quite easy, because that’s just the way you want to be treated, innit?

This is why an attitude like “All I wanna do is make and sell records” is a dead end. Because it’s just about you. It appeals only to people who care about a piece of work, not the person behind it. But these people are no fans, they’re materialists. So we run into a conundrum: What do people love first — artist or art? Legend has it that the Beatles were the prototypes of successful recording artists, but as Malcolm Gladwell points out in his book Outliers, before they became that they had to become experts in writing and performing music to a live audience. In Hamburg they learned everything they needed to succeed worldwide, because they (were forced to) put in the effort. This was as much a key ingredient as their talent and their ambition. Let’s check on these three one at a time.

Ambition: Today it makes no difference if you want to be a superstar or just aiming to make a living as a recording musician. In both careers, you have to be a person people care about, who they become a fan of, so they invest time and money in you. In return you have to give them something that exceeds their expectations, so success requires a permanent imbalance to create another transaction. If there ever is a balance, the dynamics come to a halt. Which requires one side to push or pull again, but maybe by then the fire’s gone out and the artist better reinvents himself.

Talent: The overrated ingredient. Talent is only valueable if it’s unique so it prevails. Thanks to the Internet we tend to get the notion that we’ve already seen everything that can be considered as talent, but who knows? It’s only for sure that YouTube and MySpace continuously raise the bar for the talent criterion, so it’s not sensible to rely on this only because it’s not a guarantee for future success, and the next big things are already in the queue.

Effort: The underrated ingredient, because we tend to think success is a direct product of talent, which isn’t true. But we keep telling ourselves this story so we have an excuse to procrastinate. Otherwise we would have to push ourselves every day because there is a reasonable chance that we too could be successful. Scary, huh? The truth about the Long Tail is that it becomes shorter the more effort you put in. The more you connect, the more you give, the more you show passion, the closer you get to the head.

So today all you need is these 3 attributes and some recording gear to get started. Recording gear is affordable, software is available for free as well as tutorials on every aspect of music production, which spares you a pricey studio, and you can sell your stuff through the web. The error here is the assumption of this being sufficient. It might be sufficient to enter the market, but it’s not sufficient to stand out. In order to make the rest of your odyssey as comfy as possible, you should prefer the studio, even if it’s more expensive. The spend has the free bonus of pressure so you have to focus and deliver your very best, it reminds you that this is serious.

Now it’s time to do the important work of getting the word out through the Web. There’s a notion that the few who became successful through the Internet are the exception to the rule. In fact, it’s the other way round. The exceptions have become the rules of how you can market your art over the web successfully as of today and yesterday. The takeaway is, as usual, that this is no guarantee for future success. As stated above, it’s getting harder day by day to amaze people with talent only because there is so much of it out there, and an infinite amount of semi-talent, which accounts for most of the clutter. The latter doesn’t stand a chance by itself, but once again, talent is not the crucial point, effort is. Which is why it is possible to compensate for talent by effort. It just takes more time.

Speaking of time, the upside of the Internet is that the time it takes for news to spread is basically zero. One person alone can publish her news on hundreds of channels, and if it’s picked up by a powerful sneezer it spreads like wildfire. In the days before everyone’s Internet, the artist always had an excuse by saying “It just takes more time until people notice. I’ll have to wait for more reviews in magazines, till I get played on college radio etc.” This is over. If you’re not catching on after 2 days, you better try a different approach to be recognised. So get over the disappointment, you are not a failure, you just picked the wrong method at this particular point of time. Move on.

So now the question becomes: What makes people buy music? Or stuff? Is music any different from stuff? Musicians would prefer if it were, but it isn’t. People never buy anything because it exists, so a CD sitting on a shelf will not be bought for that reason. Andy McKee used to play remarkable music back in 1999, but he was just sitting ot the shelf, until some 5 years later the YouTube hype kicked in. People buy stuff that is subject of the conversation so they can join. People buy stuff that supports the image they want to have. People buy stuff they love. People buy stuff they need to survive. If you can’t serve any of these four, you’re lost. Of course the only occasion you can take advantage of to promote your stuff is either joining or starting a conversation. The other 3 develop over time. It’s better to have people buy your stuff for image reasons than just for short term attention, its even better when people buy your stuff because they love it, and when they need it to survive, well…

Most products never exceed stage 2. This is because they don’t have a story that allows buyers to emotionally connect to, which makes being a recording artist is a … cul de sac. You’re not quite real when you don’t show up in person. Being on 2 more social networks or having 10 more videos online doesn’t compensate for not showing up. After all I know, people become really passionate fans when they’ve seen an artist perform live. Of most of the bands I got to know by going to a concert I bought a record afterwards. Funny thing is though, after a while you start telling yourself the story the other way round, the souvenir becomes the hinge and you belive you had the record first and then went to the show.

By the way, I don’t understand why some artists don’t want to perform on stage. If your art is something you love, you’d be more than happy to share it, wouldn’t you? For real. With instant feedback.

So be a person with a story people can connect to. Embrace exposure. Be different. Stand out. Put in the effort. Doesn’t work? Get more advice. Try another tactic. Repeat.

April 26, 2010

Literacy

Filed under: internet,IT — Erik Dobberkau @ 05:00

Earlier this year a study was published stating that my fellow citizens, aka Krauts, rank their computer and Internet literacy relatively high, which came quite as a surprise for me. I think it was the highest figure of all European countries compared. Last week came out a study stating that the number one country in distribution of malware and bot infected computers is — no more bets taken — Germany.

Combine that with the result of another study concluding that Facebook users (in general) are very prone to spam and abusive clicking manipulation — never mind the fact that they accuse Facebook of ignoring privacy and personal rights, but on the other hand they just click shortlinks on somebody’s wall or blindly forward them, same goes for Twitter — and you get three conclusions:

  • There won’t be less spam in the near future.
  • Antivirus and Firewall software never compensate all user responsibility deficiencies.
  • Not getting an error message doesn’t mean you’re an expert.
« Newer Posts — Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress